Leonard J. “Tony” Fenner, age 96, a lifelong resident of Plymouth, passed away peacefully on Saturday, February 7, 2026, surrounded by his loving family at The Willows at Willard.
Born June 3, 1929, in Plymouth, Leonard was the son of the late Carl and Mary (Fazio) Fenner. A proud 1947 graduate of Plymouth High School, Leonard’s roots in the community ran deep. On October 22, 1948, he married the love of his life, Kayrol (McGinty) Fenner, beginning a devoted marriage that spanned 64 years until her passing in October of 2012.
Leonard was a faithful, lifelong member of St. Joseph Catholic Church, where his faith guided him throughout his life, and was instrumental in the building of the current church. A hardworking and determined businessman, Leonard founded Fenner Plumbing & Heating on March 25, 1958, building a business that served the community for decades. Before starting his own company, he worked at New Haven Supply. In 1994, Leonard “retired” but continued to work alongside his son, Brian, for many years following.
A lifelong baseball fan, Leonard’s love for the game went beyond the stands — he even tried out for the St. Louis Browns in 1947. Above all else, Leonard treasured his family. He was a devoted father, grandfather, great-grandfather, and great-great grandfather, cheering as often as he could for any activity, sporting event, or milestone.
Leonard is survived by his children: Lynn (James) Hook of Princeton, IN, Lee (Ann) Fenner of Mansfield, Terry (Cherril) Fenner of Bellville, Karen (Ray) Hughes of Phoenix, AZ, Karla (Drew) Taylor of Leland, NC, Steve (Elaine) Fenner of Willard, Brian (Kyle) Fenner of Shelby, Jeff (Jill) Fenner of Shelby, and Beth Fenner (Aaron Raitch) of Plymouth; 15 grandchildren; 19 great-grandchildren; and 5 great-great-grandchildren; and numerous nieces, nephews, other relatives, and friends.
In addition to his wife and parents, Leonard was preceded in death by his brother: Tony Fenner; sisters: Mary Lichtle, Sallie Carney, Carolyn Predieri, and Carmella Fink; granddaughter: Dana Frankart; and great-granddaughter, Mahryah Murphy.
The family extends their heartfelt gratitude to the nurses and staff at The Willows at Willard for the compassion, care, and kindness shown to Leonard and his family.
Family and friends are invited to gather on Wednesday, February 11, 2026, from 10:00 a.m. to 12:00 noon at St. Joseph Catholic Church, 119 Sandusky Street, Plymouth. Leonard’s Funeral Mass will begin at noon, with Fr. Chris Mileski celebrating. Burial will follow in Greenlawn Cemetery, Plymouth. In lieu of flowers, memorial contributions may be made to St. Joseph Catholic Church.
Care for Leonard and his family is being provided by Penwell Funeral Home, 168 West Main Street, Shelby. Condolences may be shared on the funeral home’s website at PenwellFuneralHome.com or on its Facebook page.
Jeff and Jill you are in my prayer today and always. So sorry
I’m so sorry to hear about Leonard’s passing. What a great guy, a Plymouth fixture for sure. He will be missed. My thoughts and prayers are with all of you.
Tony and then Brian have been my plumbers for 50 years (and very good ones!). Even after Tony retired I would still call him with a problem that he would love to try to figure out. He was a great asset to the Plymouth community. He and Kayrol raised such a wonderful family. Thinking of all of you at this time. 🙏
We are so sorry to hear about Uncle Leonard’s passing. What a great life he lived and what a great family he and Aunt Kayrol raised. We were so fortunate to live near the family growing up. You all are in our prayers and thoughts.
To all the family, we send our condolences. He was such a great guy and legacy of Plymouth. He will be missed by many. Sending prayers for your comfort and peace.
Sorry for your loss. Prayers.
So Sorry to hear Of Leonard’s passing, May he Rest In Peace 🙏🏼🙏🏼
Jeff and Jill, Prayers and Condolences for you and all the family.
my condolences, to the Fenner family . He was a very kind too us boys and my family . he was very well liked in the community and well respected . once again prayers to the whole family.
So sorry for your loss 🙏❤️🙏
I am so sorry.
Leonard/Tony was a nice, congenial man. I think he might have played baseball with Larry.
My sympathy to the family.
Fenner Family: I am very sorry for your loss. May he rest in peace.
Beth, thinking of you sounds like your Dad lived a good long life, cherish the memories.
It is with our heart felt sadness of the passing of Leonard. He was a kind, loving gentleman we were privileged to be friends with for many years. We felt like part of his family in so many ways. He always made us feel welcome with a smile on his face. We are without a doubt confident he is at peace & now has joined Kayrol in heaven. You raised a wonderful family Leonard. Our hearts are with each of them. You will certainly be missed.
Lee and Brian, we are heartbroken 💔 for the loss of your father. please know we care deeply and will be praying 🙏 for your family.
Our deepest and most heartfelt condolences to your family, with the passing of your father. Our prayers are with you all for comfort and peace. May God bless your family during this period of grieving.
We are so sorry to hear of your loss. It seems he was a great man and will be missed in the community. I never met him, but knowing Ray and Karen I can see why. Our prayers are with you all. Love, Reed and Susanne
So sorry to hear of Tony’s passing. If you lived in Plymouth you knew Tony. He would always talk when you run to him. Let God be with you and let him be with you all as you go through this journey. Stay strong and hold those blessed memories close during this time and those times when you miss him. Sending our sincere condolences and keeping you all in our prayers 🙏
Our condolences to the Fenner family. Tony certainly had a rich life and left a wonderful legacy of family and friends.
Please accept my condolences on your loss. Prayers for the family.
Leonard was one of my favorites. I enjoyed working with him, and learning from him, on the Maintenance Committee at St. Joe’s Church. We really appreciated his service – almost any time of day – on our old fuel oil furnace when we lived near Plymouth. Sympathy and prayers to all the family – may he rest in peace!
Brian, Kyle & boys,
A father & grandfather that lived a full life to 96. Wow! Hold all your memories close to your heart. Prayers for all of you. Hugs
Todd & Nancy Baird
My deepest sympathy for the Fenner family. Tony was such a nice man. Always knew you and had a smile on his face. You are all in my prayers 🙏
I knew your dad for 49 years. he was a great man always loved talking with him and worked with him a few times too. may he rest in peace in the arms of the Angels
We send our sincere sympathy to the entire Fenner family. We are so sorry for your loss.
So sorry to read of the passing of your father. Our condolences to you Brian and your whole family. May your memories give you comfort and peace.